data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/6195c/6195cc52b2435d57fa7909fe316c67cee3984faa" alt=""
Swindon take home all 3 points
Plymouth Parkway v Swindon Supermarine | Match ReportParkway’s unbeaten start to 2025 ground to an abrupt halt this Saturday after Swindon Supermarine came twice from behind to claim a narrow 2-3 win at Bolitho.
A screamer from Callum Hall and a smart header from Taylor Scarff weren’t enough to seal the points for Chris McPhee’s side.
Parkway made three changes from the side that claimed late victory over Basingstoke Town with Andrew Sowden-Bird, Scarff and Matthew Wright coming in for the recent departees: Ewan Griffiths, Jack Endacott and Mitchel Beardmore.
Swindon also made a hattrick of changes with James Edge, Nicholas Peare and Harry Williams all coming into the side.
![]() ![]() 2 - 3Full Time |
Full Match Report
Parkway started the brighter of the two sides and created the first chance of the game when James Watts-Barciela cut in on his right foot from the left wing and attempted to whip the ball into the top right corner, forcing a strong diving save from Fiachra Pagel to parry wide after ten minutes.
The Yellows remained firmly on top for the opening 25 minutes and should have gone ahead when Tom Dean was found free as a bird by a cross at the back post, but the Exeter City loanee couldn’t celebrate his loan extension with a goal as he headed agonisingly wide of the far post.
Yet Parkway’s persistence paid off when last week’s match winner Callum Hall smashed an absolute rocket of a strike into the top left corner from outside of the box to give McPhee’s side a deserved 1-0 lead.
Opening the scoring solidified the hosts dominant grip on the game, yet a second headed effort from Dean and an ambitious Di Canio-like scissor kick attempt from Carlo Garside failed to find the back of the net.
Matthew Wright should have doubled Parkway’s lead heading into halftime after a marauding run down the left-hand side from defensive captain Shane White gave the forward a tap in, but the big 17 lacked conviction in the finish and his flicked attempt trickled past the post to Pagel’s relief.
Parkway were punished for their wastefulness in the first half as Swindon equalised just four minutes after the restart. Michael Elias-Fernandes had a touch of fortune that the deflected low cross rebounded into his path but made no mistake in sweeping the ball home from 12 yards to bring life back into the Supermarine.
The away side weren’t level for long as Parkway hit back with the perfect response after 56 minutes. Scarff watched Garside’s high looping corner all the way and headed home from the back post into the bottom right corner to score his first goal in Yellow.
However, a moment of madness from keeper Sowden-Bird led to a fortunate Swindon freekick on the edge of the box and once again Elias-Fernandes pounced on the chance, firing his shot through the wall and wrong-footing Sowden-Bird to drag his side level for 2-2.
The comeback was then completed by Swindon as the inform Elias-Fernandes toyed with debutant Tylor Love-Holmes before clipping a ball to the back post which was headed back across goal for Harry Williams to poke into the back of the net in the 73rd minute.
The chances and decisions just simply wouldn’t fall in Parkway’s favour in the second half, which was epitomised when Supermarine’s Nicholas Peare fortunately avoided a red card for a high and late challenge on Garside.
Further questions were asked when referee Luke McFarlane waved away bellowing calls from the Bolitho faithful for a last-minute penalty appeal after the ball struck an outstretched arm in Swindon’s box.
But despite Parkway relentless pressure for that craved late equaliser, Swindon’s defence stayed resolute as the full-time whistle went.
Speaking after the match McPhee said:
“I’m gutted. The players are devastated and obviously massively frustrated as a group of people because across the 108 minutes we were by far the better team for massive parts of that game.”
“Looking back two of their goals should have been disallowed but I felt the big key decisions just didn’t go our way today. Some of those decisions are quite obvious in what they should be but it’s football.
“We’ve got to be in a position where we’re not too disheartened, we’ve got to be hurt and scorned by what’s happened today but we’ve got to use that as fuel to go again Tuesday against Bracknell Town and make sure we’re not in that position again through learning from every experience and moving forward.”
Match Info
Plymouth Parkway:
1 Sowden-Bird, 2 Dean, 5 Scarff, 6 White, 7 Williams, 8 Hall, 10 Garside, 16 Endacott (Love Holmes 45), 17 Wright (Ismail 66), 19 Watts-Barciela (Cunningham 66), 20 Garside.
Subs: 3 Joce (unused), 4 Brett (unused), 9 Ismail, 14 Love-Holmes, 18 Cunningham.
Yellows:
Endacott 17, Hall 39, Garside 45, Garside 97.
Swindon Supermarine:
1 Pagel, 2 Turl, 3 Campbell, 4 Lee, 5 Richards, 6 Edge, 20 Peare, 8 Ibrahim (Dworzak 66), 9 Williams, 10 Elias-Fernandes (Reivers 80), 11 Mehew (Vine 69).
Subs:
12 Dworzak, 13 Brabham (unused), 14 Vine, 15 Reivers, 16 Sonoiki (unused).
Yellows:
Turl 35, Peare 79.